Aaron Aaronson probably should have been an Erin. Her parents hadn’t realized the Aa-spelling of the name was typically reserved for the masculine but it looked so appealing on the birth certificate with the double a’s of the last name that her father, amateur semiotician, professional poet, a man who though pretty much safe with a low lottery number nevertheless volunteered for combat duty in Vietnam so as to have something to write about — his slim volume of war verse, Baptisms in the Ben Hai, won a bevy of awards, was a runner-up for the Pulitzer, and was perhaps the last book of poetry to sell over fifty thousand copies — a person enamored with the couplings and mingling of letters on the page, preferred it anyway. Aaron Aaronson was born on December 31st, 1984, which she forever argued was the worst day of the year to have a birthday (much worse than Christmas). The story went that her first word was “dada”, her second “mama”, and her third “quatrain”, although she had been staring out the window at a rail yard at the time.
She was an only child if you didn’t count her siblings. Which she didn’t. They were halfsies anyway. Three sisters, triplets, Grace, Harmony, and Charity, were born to her mother Peg and Peg’s second husband Troy more than a decade after she and Adam Aaronson had divorced and quite a few years after Peg had turned forty. Several rounds of in vitro and voila!, a gaggle of three freshly-minted baby girls, sixteen years Aaron’s junior. Now the Tomlinsons resided in Delray Beach, Florida, and the triplets were finishing their sophomore year of high school. They gazed upon Aaron as if she was some alien life-form come to call from the Planet Millenial, which perhaps they’d heard tell about in the blogosphere, or Western Civ. During her last visit there Grace had slipped and called her “Aunt Aaron.” It was all enough to make a thirty-one year old woman feel old.
Another thing that will age you: a dying parent. Not a dead one per se, not a one killed in a car crash or felled by coronary thrombosis or drowned in a riptide. No, the dying, the decline, the lazy switchback of gradually encroaching illnesses. Adam Aaronson’s dying was composed of several components, a generalized entropy: gathering emphysema from years and years of heavy smoking, an ailing liver from years and years of hard drinking, some erosion to his nervous system — the drinking again, and pills, and the PTSD that due to the era was never properly diagnosed (modest royalties and eventual tenure at Hunter College had not come without a price) — to go along with the gastric distress caused by his peculiar eating habits (he didn’t) and worsening glaucoma, which no amount of Acapulco Gold or Lebanese hash had been able to stymie. Still a handsome man in his weathered West Texas way, he didn’t come off especially older than his sixty-two years, so long as you didn’t note the egg yolk yellow of the whites around his eyes, or mark how his hand trembled when reaching for a ballpoint pen or highball glass, or listen too closely to the humid sound of his inhales and exhales, the shallow, puddled quality of them.
Her favorite of her father’s poems was one called “The Collaborators”, from a mid-period collection cooly received by critics (“formerly one of America’s more interesting young poets, a direct descendent of Lowell both in the Confessional movement and his engagement with public topics, forgoing, however, free verse in his first works to employ a tightly controlled, almost formalist style having much in common with the realist school of minimalist literature, Adam Aaronson has too long now been mining a terrain where his innate gifts for the pungent phrase, the unsparing viewpoint, and an empathy with hard human truths are simply not to be found, under sway as he has been to the looser, elliptical abstractions of Ashbery, Lauterbach, Schuyler, et al….” So read The Kenyon Review’s assessment of Rheingold Dreams, a review her father had cut out and pinned to the cork board above his desk, as he did with every pan he came across, the thing now so glommed with scraps of paper it looked like the kiosk of a student union). Fairly frequently Aaron sat down with her guitar and the poem carefully copied out into one of her composition books, and tried to work up chord changes and an encompassing melody for the words. For years now it had defeated her. Admittedly the whole enterprise was pretty perverse; “The Collaborators” was indeed free verse, had no formal structure, no consistent meter, no music ready-made to leap out of the lines. Her own original songs were poppy and punchy, taut and economical. Her father’s earliest poems would have been more conventional candidates for recasting into song form , disciplined and streamlined as they were (even if she couldn’t quite hear herself singing about bandoliers and rucksacks, frag grenades or buck privates named Bobby). Why she’d chosen this particular one she really couldn’t say; at some point the notion came to roost and was still hanging around, always cawing in the background. Perhaps the attraction stemmed from it being such an absurd quest, and because “The Collaborators” was so unlike her own work. She revered it as something she could never herself conceive of doing.
They lived together now, she and her father. Rather, she’d moved into his place, a rent-controlled two bedroom on Columbus and 97th. A perfectly good apartment, albeit musty, cluttered and dim, as was his way and as had been hers ever since leaving spick-and-span, duvet and dust-ruffled Peg’s house at seventeen to attend SUNY at Stony Brook. In short order from then had followed two semesters of academic probation, ultimately expulsion; then a studio apartment on Avenue C shared with with her three band mates at the time; a record deal with Matador; some gigs opening for Sleater-Kinney on a leg of their North American tour; a dalliance with heroin; getting clean; then a two-year relationship with a Chinese-American woman named Li that ended in more devastation and heartbreak than even a willful relapse could salve. One night she loaded up too much into the syringe, laid down on the rug in the bathroom, and commenced to stare at the ceiling light. Next thing she knew fluorescents were whipping overhead as her gurney was being hustled down a hospital hallway, her throat scorched and her blood on fire, Aaron narrowly plucked from extinction by happenstance when a roommate’s girlfriend got up in the middle of the night to pee.
Was the O.D. intentional or just a mishap? Did she actually die for a few seconds, or only almost? After the ordeal she wrote a song called “Turning Blue” that attempted, if not to answer those questions, then to at least mediate them, give voice to their relative importance. Conclusion? They weren’t very important at all.
Neither was the song very good. In it she’d worked with an extended metaphor — the notion of sadness, the “blues”, in the aftermath of romantic disintegration, interwoven with the details of an overdose. But it hadn’t come off really, felt labored and too clever by half. It did however give her the first real taste of how exquisite failure could be, the poignant attachment you could have for a creation that didn’t quite succeed. An admirable failure, a song that almost touched another place, a place she’d never before been. Also it sported a killer lick she’d nicked from a Split Enz’s B-side to go along with a good recording, muddy and raw, engineered by a guy named Dillweed in a defunct taxidermy shop in Bay Ridge repurposed into an analogue studio. “Turning Blue” did nothing in the States but became a minor hit in Central Europe. To this day, at random unexpected moments, a check would arrive, cut by some subsidiary label in The Hague or Bonn. the last one was for four hundred and eleven dollars and forty-seven cents. Maybe the money was negligible, but gratifying was the reminder that some seed of hers had found purchase in a far off part of the world and there had flowered, a tiny, tattered puny little rose—pretty nonetheless. Something had happened.
Her father rarely got drunk anymore; his stomach couldn’t tolerate it. Adam Aaronson more or less subsisted on a daily basis in a benign fuzzy state of tipsy. Nursing a Lord Calvert with two ice cubes and a splash of soda water, averaging one every couple of hours, seven to ten a day. For a terminal case, Aaron thought, it really isn’t so much, not when you break it down. The cigarettes were a different story — those he was unremittingly suicidal over, smoking one after the next with the avidity of a kamikaze pilot making for the nearest aircraft carrier. “What,” he’d say, or croak, gurgle, wheeze or hack, depending on the hour, after she’d once again scolded him, “they found a cure for emphysema?”
“I hear it’s scheduled for this time next year. You’ll want to be around for it. Give the Reds a rest.”
“Great. Health tips from the junkie.”
“I quit. See how that works?”
“There’s no point living just to be miserable. Let’s say I toss them, live an extra five years. That’s five years, fiending nonstop, thinking ‘goddamn, sure could use a smoke.’”
“Come again,” said Aaron. “Didn’t quite catch that last part. Voice got sorta wispy there at the end.”
He sang a snatch of the tune to The Yellow Rose of Texas, inserting “Go to hell, go to hell…” in place of the opening lyric. Leaning forward in his swivel chair, he rubbed at the fine burr of white-flecked stubble nestled at the corners of his mouth, pushed the half-moon reading spectacles up the bridge of his nose and peered close at the sheet of paper in the cradle of the manual Smith Corona on the desk.
He clicked up the roller, opened the lever and pulled free the paper. “See what you think,” he said. “Just started it.”
Thus far it was only five lines, no breaks. Five short lines, unlike the rolling, free-flowing verse that had been characteristic of his work for a long time now. Still, Aaron was forced to count out the syllables silently; truth be told, she was often stumped by poetry, had trouble on first read gleaning the music in it. Sometimes she thought it all a bluff — there was no music to be had. And she was often challenged even by the rudiments of versification. Meter was difficult for her to ascertain, the fall of the stresses on the syllables striking her as arbitrary. Without a melody to unlock the form, she was pretty much a novice.
The five lines here were all six syllables. And, the poem rhymed, a true rarity in the Aaronson oeuvre. Aa, bb, c…The fifth line was Calm eyes has the crazed dove.
She handed him back the sheet of paper. “Well, it’s a beginning. You’re rhyming. That’s different. Listen, take it from the songstress. Whatever you do, don’t use ‘love’ to go with ‘dove’. You’re in hack territory then. You’re Hallmark.”
“It’s not about the rhyme,” he said, folding his hands over his stomach. She could tell he was feeling expansive. “That’s the challenge. ‘Love’ would be fine, but the words that come before have to validate its presence. Have to vindicate its use. You can fall into the trap where you’re just contorting yourself, using whatever dreck beforehand, whatever filler, to get to the rhyme. No, can’t be done that way. Has to appear all at once, organically, the way these first five lines did.”
“So, any ideas for the sixth yet? Organic ideas, I mean.”
“I’ve got one percolating. Not going to rush it. I’ll fix a drink first, let it steep.”
“Sure. Go ahead and mix your metaphors while you’re at it.”
He turned his head to her, all blithe boredom. “Do you know the great weakness of your generation? An addiction to glibness.”
To parry this, she said nothing, even two or three very glib rejoinders sizzled in her brain. She stood and he held out his empty glass. In the kitchen she dropped in three cubes of ice, poured in half a tumbler of whiskey, and topped it with an extra spritz of soda water.
In the study, he’d already taken up a book and was reading. The crow’s feet around his eyes flexed in the intensity of his squint. The Complete Stories of Flannery O’Connor. She read the story’s title along the top of the left page. “A Late Encounter with the Enemy”. Without looking up, he took the glass from her. “Thank you, sweetie.”
More than once he had announced his intention to wend his way back through his favorite books and authors, giving them a final loving reread, before his eyes, or he himself, cashed out. She watched as he read. The authors he was revisiting were almost entirely American, and outside of Twain and Melville, almost all twentieth-century. All prose — he read very little poetry these days. Of course in his youth he’d been smitten by Keats and Shelley and Byron, by the Beats, by Rimabaud and Verlaine and Valery, then later Paz and Neruda. It was typical of the dichotomies within him that his truest, most sustaining passions were for authors who worked in basically a different medium from his own, his current reading a stroll in the field of fiction which he himself had never plowed, earnestly finding fulfillment in that which was recent (but not so recent), close to home (and yet very far away).The novels of Faulkner’s great period, Bellow’s Augie March and Henderson, Cheever’s short stories, Dos Passos and Eudora Welty. That which was so foreign to his work, and yet so familiar to his self.
But then he had always been an outsider, or outlier, in many ways. Never quite fitting into a movement, a period, stubbornly resistant to embrace even by something so consolidating as geography. He’d been in the city nearly a quarter of a century at this point, after years of moving Aaron and her mother across the country as the teaching jobs arose: Austin to Champagne, Illinois, to Charlottesville, Virginia — and still he seemed distinctly un-New York. In the aisles of a Gristedes he looked like some provincial dad in from the sticks, bewildered by the artisan cheeses and gourmet foodstuffs. He’d done readings at the 92nd Street Y, at the KGB bar, attended PEN conferences, had known George Plimpton, used to talk to him regularly on the telephone. There was a rumor that he’d once bedded Susan Sontag (Aaron had eagerly inquired more than once; he remained coyly noncommittal on the subject). And yet he remained impenetrable to cosmopolitan seepage and literary culturing, the stamp of western America indelible upon him even after all this time. He favored flannel work shirts, jeans and chinos. He always looked as if he should be standing on the porch of a cabin, sipping his whiskey from a coffee mug. Relatively sedentary as most of his adulthood had been, the life of a poet and academic, still he had broad shoulders and thick wrists, pronounced veins coursing up his forearms.
“You have a birthday coming up,” Aaron said.
“I’ll take your word for it,” he replied, never taking his eyes off the book.
“Do you think that sixth line will come soon?”
“No, I think not.”
***
Aaron unpacked her guitar. Candy tightened down the high hat on her kit. Wittier thumbed the low E string of her Rickenbacker bass. Dum, dum-du-dum.
Around them Jorquis was adjusting the microphones, getting levels, running back and forth to his MacBook Pro. QuickenDed was his baby, and he’d been running the podcast out of his parents basement for a couple of years now. A disjointed enterprise of love, catch as catch can, some weeks three or four episodes aired, then there might elapse a whole month of web silence.
Aaron hated in-studio performances. Hate, a strong word, one she knew generally served as a pseudonym for fear. What are you afraid of? This was an exercise recommended by a former therapist to be undertaken in any situation which she found daunting or in which she felt herself uncomfortable. Aaron was supposed to answer it specifically. Actually the therapist’s exact recommendation had been to ask, “What am I afraid of?” But, being herself, Aaron had tweaked it, rendering it in second-person, a common songwriter device, to mitigate some of the solipsism and lend the question a double-edged, accusatory quality. A small shift perhaps, but one she found congenial.
I am afraid of the naked quality of live performance without an audience. They were recording live — Jorquis didn’t do multiple takes. So without crowd noise, without monitors feeding back and muffled acoustics and room echo, without beer, there was nowhere for her to hide. I am afraid because I am not a good guitar player. No phony self-deprecation there; she knew it was just the humble fact. She’d started playing around puberty and ceased advancing on the instrument about the time she got her learner’s permit. Primitive rhythm, strumming, banging out some chords to serve as ballast beneath the vocals — this was pretty much the sum of her proficiency. Every so often she tried to pick up a new tuning, or work some arpeggios into her technique. Progress: minimal.
The current band was called Diamond Jill, and, regrettably, it was a three-piece, Aaron carrying guitar chores alone. Once upon a time a girl named Renee had handled lead duties. A total hot-shit player, only she insisted on bringing her cats to rehearsal, all four of them. Freed from their crates the cats would hiss and mewl, scamper over amps and claw at the power cables. When Wittier, Diamond Jill’s resident hard ass, confronted her on the issue, bespectacled Renee, looking like nothing so much as the world’s cutest librarian, flipped open a Spiderco and cut loose with a torrent of savage, unhinged threats that froze even the felines in their stances of blithe mischief. So — delicately, diplomatically — the lead guitarist was told, hey, no hard feelings, you know, things aren’t working out, let’s just go our separate ways. This Renee took exceedingly well; violent mania vanishing in an instant, she corralled Measles and Mumps, Romulus and Remus back inside their crates, took up her guitar case, and even laden with all that cargo had somehow managed a goodbye wave as she went out the door. What Aaron wouldn’t give for that sort of dexterity.
An impromptu decision had been made to start with “Stomp in the Name of Love”, to be followed up by “Chain Stores,” before wrapping up the mini-set with “Hausfrau”. Each presented their own perils for Aaron. “Stomp” in its recorded version kicked off with a choppy, start-and-stop riff, not complex but staccato, and for this performance Aaron asked Candy to click out time with her sticks and give the snare a whap before Aaron hit the first down stroke on her guitar, nervous that otherwise she might goof the opening and mess up the song from the get-go.
But it went fine. She fell in with Candy’s beat, stuck herself like a limpet to Wittier’s bass line, and found a suitable yowling register for her vocals, not opening up the throttle too much lest she overwhelm Jorquis’s close-miking.
As ever a decent rendition of a song relaxed Aaron considerably. And “Chain Stores” started out with a bass and toms groove, requiring only a few blurps of random guitar squall on the verses before the explosion of a righteous power-chord chorus, two chords and all attack. That she could do.
What are you afraid of? The true issue, thought Aaron, is I’m not a performer. Not really. I’m a writer. In fact she’d maybe never been a performer, not at heart, and had only survived her first fledgling decade as a front girl through a combination of youthful bravado and smack. Those aids having long-since fled or been disavowed, now she stood stripped in front of a Neumann mike, and her wasn’t a matter of fear, at least not solely so. I’m just not that into this. It bored her, playing live; she no longer enjoyed it. The guiding principle of music, her kind of music at least, was passion. Passion and authenticity. Any ebb in the former and you utterly lacked the latter.
She didn’t think this realization was necessarily a bad thing. For a certain type of temperament, life can seem a steady shutting of doors. A process of paring, abnegation. It meant only that one’s calling was becoming more channeled, concentrated. You are not this, not that, are not this other thing either. You say no to a bunch of things so that to one thing, one glorious thing, you can bestow a huge unreserved YES.
The possibility this might be a rationalization for the encroachment of apathy was not lost on her.
Her defense against said possibility was to write. Constantly. All the time. She wrote a minimum of a couple of hours every day, usually much more. Knowing other songwriters and musicians (other than her father, they were the sum of her acquaintanceship), proved to her how unusual this was. Other peoples’ songs were generally written in rehearsal, occasionally sound checks, in beer and pizza jam sessions late at night after everyone had gotten tired of bashing out covers on their acoustics. A few of the tech heads composed on their computers, using software, rhythm tracks (completely valid — she was no purist). But regardless of method, for everyone else it seemed the writing came in spates, in certain contexts, in the intervals between things. For her, increasingly giving a lick and a stamp to everything else, the creating was the centerpiece, what she did and what she built around. The means and the end. Maybe I don’t know how else to spend my day.
So the pages and notebooks piled up, as did the DAT tapes (laughably archaic as those already were). Some songs she didn’t even record — some of them good ones. She just wrote them, played them to herself in her bedroom at night, and released them to the ether as an almost Dadaist joke on the idea of permanence. Other songs she never finished, or hadn’t as of yet. Third verses or middle-eighths — her sixth lines — were still percolating, would one day come to a boil, or not. Anyway, she was in the process of surrendering outcomes.
The usual format of QuickenDed was for a band to play two songs, then settle in for a few minutes of an informal interview with Jorquis before the closing number. Patter tended to be very glib indeed. She being the singer and main songwriter, there was the tacit understanding that Jorquis would basically be interviewing her.
Jorquis: “You played where last week? Arlene’s,wasn’t it?”
Aaron: “Yep. Arlene’s.”
Jorquis: “Good show.”
Aaron: “Good venue. Oh sure, we were stellar.”
Jorquis: “What’s your favorite place to play?”
Aaron: “My favorite place? That would be my bedroom.”
Jorquis: “Public place, let’s say.”
Aaron: “Oh, let’s just go ahead and say Arlene’s. I’m sure the Beacon Theatre is very nice, but we wouldn’t know.”
Jorquis: “Haven’t broken through to the Beacon yet, huh?”
Aaron: “Not yet. But it’s on our bucket list. And can’t forget Madison Square. I hear that’s a good one.”
Jorquis: “Yeah, Kings of Leon told me the same thing.”
Aaron: “See, I’d have thought they were Hollywood Bowl types.”
Wittier, chiming in off mike: “Staples Center, I bet.”
Some laughter. Aaron: “Yeah, right. Sure. Staples Center. They’re those kind of guys.”
Jorquis: “Ok. So what next for Diamond Jill?”
Aaron: “Where next, or what next?”
Jorquis: “Either/or. Or neither.”
Aaron: “I choose neither.”
It came off as more curt than she had intended, yet she didn’t attempt to elaborate or add to the answer. The interview ended on that awkward note; the recording picked up the slightly uncomfortable titters of her band mates.
The song “Hausfrau” dated from early in the previous decade, and was probably Aaron’s most widely-known song — a very relative term. It had a distinctive double-tap drum break, verses with a quasi-nursery rhyme quality, and an exploding one word refrain that had all the insistence of a Gregorian chant in 4/4 time. “Housewife!” Most people indeed thought this was the title. Aaron had performed it probably two hundred times. Which did not prevent her from royally fucking it up now. She stroked the final chord change to B7 flat as a flapjack, didn’t recover from the flub fast enough, lost her entire strum pattern for a second and slid a quarter note behind the rhythm section. Wittier and Candy tried to adjust, tried to ease off the tempo just a tad, but of course at the same instant Aaron was scrambling to catch up, sending the performance at first wobbling and then careening and then capsizing it altogether, the entire mess finally stumbling to a halt not with any ragged grace or defiance but rather meekly, apologetically, as the band simply quit the song to the mortified embarrassment of sterile studio silence.
That night she lay back on her bed, notebook beside her, guitar in an open tuning. And again she tried to cajole “The Collaborators” into being music. And failed. Again. This on its own wouldn’t have been so bad — wasn’t the first time after all. But with the guitar laid by, as Aaron tripped off to sleep, she heard it, the elusive, impossible song, heard it of a whole, distant but crystalline, like the sound of laughter coming from the opposite shore of a lake. The song was there, across some dreamy expanse, allowing her to eavesdrop as it serenaded itself.
***
Adam Aaronson’s sixty-fourth birthday fell on a lovely and warm April day. Aaron mandated a lunch date to celebrate. This was done to at least get her father out of doors; an always hermetic tendency had of late begun to drift into agoraphobic territory.
An organic fusion place with patio seating. They ordered wine, Adam got the jerk chicken with sweet potato frites, Aaron a cup of cucumber gazpacho and sides of tabouli and bok choy. The world of the Upper West Side went by their table, and she watched it less than she watched her dad watching it, slowly following the passersby with his ailing eyes. Only if they were blonde and pretty, and nowhere near celebrating their sixty-third birthdays, did his eyes evince any interest.
On his second glass of Malbec he turned more talkative. “You okay for money?”
“After springing for lunch, no. I foresee red in my account.”
“Christ, I’ll get lunch.”
“No, I got it. You only turn ancient once. My treat. I’m broke anyway, let’s all have steak.”
He leaned forward a bit, looking down into his wineglass. “What are you going to do when I’m gone.”
“No, no. Absolute nyet. We’re not going there. Balmy weather and talk of the shroud go together not at all.”
“Really,” he said. “Seems a natural association to me.”
“What is this? Birthdays usually don’t get to you like this. I mean, you’ve wanted to be an old man your whole life. What is this elegiac thing you’re doing right now?”
He shrugged, sighed, sat back. He looked small in his seat. “It’s my eyes. I don’t always realize how bad they’ve become. It’s as if everything is wrapped in clouds.”
She had the urge to reach out and take his hand in hers. But didn’t do it. What are you afraid of? “Meh, just an optical illusion. Your eyes are adjusting to the sun. They’d forgotten what it looked like. Too long in the cave.”
She had been heartened when on receiving the food he started in eating right away. After a few bites this dwindled to just pushing slivers of chicken around with his fork. Then he lit a cigarette, though the patio, along with the city, was non-smoking. Which made her very anxious, on behalf of the server. She herself had spent years in the restaurant industry and this had made her distinctly sensitive on the matter of patron etiquette. Adam Aaronson for his part seemed unaware he’d even lit the thing. He took a couple of automatic puffs, then just let it smolder between his fingers, ash dropping onto his shirtfront. “Spoken to your mother lately?”
Aaron suspected there was a breed of divorced men who were always asking this question, or always wanting to, a reconnoitering for information about the ex, hungry for details about the loves and life of the once-significant other — for all she knew they comprised the majority of the species. Adam Aaronson was decidedly not of those. Never in Aaron’s memory did she remember him appearing wistful or nostalgic for his previous life as a spouse. For a long time Aaron had credited this to a natural reticence, before concluding that these feelings were not being concealed, they were non-existent. On the subject of his marriage to her mother, Adam Aaronson expressed only indifference or relief, and even those were rare.
“Yeah,” she said. “Last week or maybe the week before. She’s fine. The same. Chirpy.”
The answer apparently striking him as entirely sufficient, he pursued the topic no further.
Aaron recalled a conversation — even more brief — from several years ago, when it had been her asking him a question. Sometime in her late teens she had finally grown curious about his work, having to that point known basically nothing about it, a dad’s job description always a dull thing for an adolescent even if that job happens to be lyric poet. She spent a summer reading through the corpus, in chronological order. And like the commonest of critics found herself at first liking most the compact early pieces, the gritty, true-to-life stuff. So she’d asked him one day, foolishly she now thought, naively, why he didn’t write poems like that anymore.
“Because I love poems like that too much.”
And how this answer struck her then in a similar manner: entirely sufficient.
The following night he fell in the shower. She was in the kitchen at the time. There was the sound of running water, then came two hard thumps and a wet-sounding smack, this in turn followed by a hollow sort of clatter.
She opened the door to find him sprawled on the floor, naked and thrashing beneath the fallen shower curtain.
“Sonofabitch,” he grunted, trying to push himself up.
Aaron turned off the water and bent down to him.
His bottom lip was split open and bleeding, and already his chin had started to swell. “Sonofabitch, goddamn sonofabitch.”
“Easy,” she said.
She put her arms around him and tried to pull him upright. A rending gasp tore through him, and he heaved and spilled out of the embrace, flopping face down.
“Where are you hurt,” she said, trying to keep her voice even and assured.
He was wheezing now. He gestured at his left side, from hipbone up and down again.
“Here, just lay still.”
She tugged the shower curtain free of the last remaining rings on the rod and spread it over his waist. His feet stuck out, white as tissue paper from the ankles down, the toenails turned to horn, hard yellow husks. She positioned herself behind him, brought his sopping head and shoulders into her lap. The soaking fringe of his hair fell over his brow, clung to his cheeks.
Even the slightest movement triggered a clench and a shudder. He’d almost certainly broken at least one rib, maybe cracked his pelvis or hip. “Here, calm down,” she said. “Calm down and try to take deep breaths.”
“Hurts like a sonofabitch.”
“I know it does. Just slow your breathing. In a minute I’ll call an ambulance.”
Grunting, he said, “Don’t need one. Don’t need a doctor.”
“That’s nice, Hemingway. I’ll be the judge of that. Go ahead and put the stoic doll back inside the box, and breathe.”
The tiles of the floor were washed over with water; her pajama bottoms grew soggy. The room was silent for a minute except for his pained breaths and a drip from the faucet echoing down the drain. She observed his pale, freckled shoulders, still fairly-well muscled but knobby at the bones, the skin webbed and scalloped.
She said, “I’ve been trying to set one of your poems to music.”
For several seconds he didn’t respond. When he did, the words came haltingly, between the catches of sharp breaths. “Which one?”
“The Collaborators.”
More silence. Then, “I don’t …I don’t remember it.”
This surprised her. “Really? You don’t?”
“Wrote a thousand of the things. How old?”
“It’s from the Rheingold Dreams collection. I think, ’85, ’86.”
“Okay,” he said. “Start it off for me.”
The Collaborators
Close the afternoon down and board it up,
Grab hat and coat, spike the lemonade.
Bamboo gardens, fig feathers, amethyst house plants,
Grab them.
The white apples, the red grapes — grab them.
We spent Saturday setting stones
And digging Spanish moss, talking
To mosquitoes, shaking hands with
Our fists; Sundays spent
On the roof, pointing her to
The Rhymney bells and hiding
Aesop under the mattress.
Demotic bliss, grab it, it comes
In shards. One day I’ll say goodbye
To all of this, and will remember more
Than ever was there, about
how my allies and I used to pitch our tents
In corn fields, how we redrew constellations
With two fingers, how we scoured the vegetables
For faint magic.
My associations all will one day end,
Partnerships dissolved. The collaborations though,
They endure. What we wrote in seconds,
Each taking a word, trading off meaning,
Shaking free the sense. In the easy grasses
We named her, her syllables
Yours, mine, ours, her own.
Here it is night, now comes the night,
And June bugs pop
The window screens.
I hear the name, and its sound
Is my sound.
I am always leaving, I always remain.
She hadn’t realized she had memorized it.
“You recite well. I’d forgotten all about that one.”
“Well trying to make a song of it might be the dumbest idea ever. It doesn’t circle, there’s no repetition. Each time I try it’s just some meandering improvisation, no structure. I’d have to be Charles Mingus or somebody to pull it off.”
His grunt sounded like an assent; a chuckle gurgled somewhere in the back of his throat. It was cut off by another gasp. “Don’t be afraid, the clown’s a-a-afraid too. But, yeah. Yes. Tough task you picked there.”
“I couldn’t tell you why I’m so drawn to it. I don’t have the foggiest what it’s about.” This she said despite cringing that even in his injured state he might embark on one of his patented polemics on how poems aren’t about anything, how understanding is a fallacy. And so on.
His breaths had perhaps calmed a bit. “Sure you do, darling.”
He called her “darling” maybe two or three times a year. Whenever he did, only then would she realize that she wished he’d say it more. “Alright,” she said, “I’ll bite. What’s it about?”
“Darling,” –two in a row!—“it’s about you.”
We named her…pointing her…I hear the name, and its sound…Aesop….Obvious when you know.
“It’s about me,” she said. A statement.
“Well, sort of. It is, and isn’t. Started out about you, became what they’re all about.”
“Which is what exactly?”
“Itself. All of them really are about … about themselves.”
She patted the crown of his head, stroked back his hair. “There there, shut up. Your first answer was better. Think you can get up now?”
He couldn’t. She called 911. The paramedics arrived and lifted him onto a stretcher; by the time they loaded him into the ambulance the gasps had petered out. She rode in the back with him to the hospital.
It was after three a.m. when she returned to the apartment alone. In the kitchen she made one of his drinks, stiffer than the ones she mixed for him. She went into the study, sat down in his chair, inhaled the room’s strong cologne of him, his cigarette smoke, his abiding atmosphere.
Switching on the desk lamp. The Smith Corona, the same sheet of paper in the cradle. Still just the five lines. He’d never gotten the sixth one down.
But she had one. It tumbled from the preceding five as an inevitability, snapped into place like a jigsaw piece. No other line could have fitted.
She tapped it out on the keys, counted out the syllables to be sure, guessed at where the stress marks belonged. And it worked, it scanned. It even rhymed.